Can I take a moment to tell you all about something amazing? In recent years, the place of trans women in pornography has been a topic of hot debate within trans communities, and a site of some awesome activism. Some of this activism has included Tobi Hill-Meyer’s seminal Doing it Ourselves: Trans Women Porn Project, which featured queer trans women in a feminist porn context. That movie brought a lot of issues around transmisogyny to light, and queer trans women have been making serious inroads into the feminist porn world as a result.
But what about straight trans women? So often trans activism focuses on one specific trans experience: that of a mostly white, exclusively queer kind of trans person. Straight trans women have been left out of the conversation. And when we talk about straight trans woman porn, we can see only typical tranny and shemale porn produced for a cis male gaze.
Well, legendary feminist pornographer Nica Noelle has changed that. She has started a new studio called Trans Romantic that creates porn specifically catering to the desires of straight trans women and other trans women who like cis men. This is stuff made for a trans woman’s gaze. The first title in this series, Forbidden Lovers, has a plotline about a cis man taking his trans woman girlfriend home to meet his parents, before she’s disclosed being trans. When she does disclose, they have amazing and hot sex! The non-sex parts are super cute and really romantic and lovely. Dreamy!
The great thing about this is that the men are really hot! Tranny and shemale porn are stigmatized industries, meaning that male performers often won’t be able to return to straight or gay porn if they do tranny or shemale porn, and that results in usually really unattractive/boring guys doing it with super babely trans ladies. Nica Noelle has found REALLY HOT GUYS who are excited to be part of these films! This is a big deal in the porn world.
I absolutely loved Forbidden Lovers, and I’m not even straight. Want to support things for trans women and not just your tiny bubble of acceptably queer ones? SUPPORT TRANS ROMANTIC!!
Edited to add: Also! These movies are produced with plotlines that show trans women as not only objects of desire, but SUBJECTS OF LOVING RELATIONSHIPS. That is hugely revolutionary.
I’m really excited to see this and would love to get a chance to check it out sometime soon. I can in the notes on this post that some folks are critiquing it for various reasons and I’d just like to put this in the context of trans-positive work coming out of the mainstream industry. Yeah, it’s inevitably going to have some issues that are problems in more anti-oppression spaces. It’s not currently possible to get rid of all that and still distribute (let alone produce) in the mainstream industry. But the shift towards trans women taking more control in the production of mainstream porn and actually creating it with trans women in mind as an audience — that is a mind blowingly amazing progression and deserves to be celebrated!
Also, I’ll mention that in my own productions I have been frustrated at not having been able to include straight trans women. In my current project I’ve made a significant outreach effort to include more trans women with men (particularly cis men, as I haven’t had that in a film before) and I’m excited about the turnout. And just like how recruiting through mainstream channels has it’s problems, recruiting through feminist/queer porn channels has it’s problems too. One of them is that there are significantly fewer straight trans women (or other trans women involved with men, particularly cis men). It’s made this outreach difficult. Noting that, I’m really excited to see this project moving forward and can’t wait to see what else Trans Romantic produces.
(And btw, while the casting for trans women with cis partners has closed, I’m still casting for trans women with trans partners and am particularly looking for more trans women with trans men. If you’re complaining about trans men not being involved in Trans Romantic, let me point you to my casting call: http://blog.handbasketproductions.com/?p=290)
Adding to comments, this maybe hasn’t even been mentioned, but nica has no clue about actual trans issues. I spoke with her personally before she started these films, and she told me how her brother “who is gay” only dates “drag queens and ladyboys” and how she wanted to do “romantic shemale porn” - and then got confused when I said “you mean trans women” - she had to have me clarify what “trans women” meant (I think she thought I meant ftm.)
Also, that photo looks heavily photoshopped - did she alter the womans face and body? It looks a little blurry/painted.
Also, she is very blatantly against sex work, and has publicly shamed escorts for “bringing stds into the industry. ” and her arguement got worse as people questioned her logic. She Insists that she only wants to work with performers that are “loyal to the industry” and “classy”, not whores and prostitutes. So that sucks.
She did hire a drew deveaux, a trans woman, in an all-girl lesbian feature (where theyall role play that they really are straight, but drunk…) - but I’m pretty sure she wasnt aware that drew was trans until after the film was made, at which point in her defense, she tried to stand up to her distributor, who had anti-trans policies in thier contract. But that was the end of that collaboration.
She is not a rad woman. At least not how I see it. Movies like this do seem really, really awesome and badly needed, but I regret that this woman may not be the straight porn savior we are looking for.
I am excited to see tobi’s new work, and have myself been shooting some scenes between trans women and men. There needs to be more, and I wish someone like tristan taormino or nina Hartley would do straight trans-inclusive features.
(I’m responding on my phone using speech to text. Revised for typos as much as I could, but plz forgive any oversights.)
Reblogging for ALL the commentary. This is an important conversation.
Really important.
My doctor, who is a trans woman, and I had a conversation today about the guy who raped me earlier this year. At first she was like “did you charge him?” When I explained that he’s a trans man of colour, she immediately got why I hadn’t. Not because I couldn’t bare to put a trans person,…
Signal-boosting!!!
(Also, I am so psyched that Lily Butter/Sybil Lamb’s work is being included. I’ve only ever read & seen her stuff online. I kinda wish I could get to Toronto to see it in a gallery/performance setting.)
TWAT/fest!!
Trans Women’s Arts Toronto festival!
Please share widely!!
AUGUST 9th 2012
at Buddies in Bad Times Theatre
Experience cutting edge video, performance, new media, and visual art created by trans woman-identified (and trans female-spectrum) artists in the world’s first trans women’s fine arts festival. Curated and organized by Morgan M Page.
Featuring work by
Mirha-Soleil Ross (Montreal)
Izzy Ellis (Toronto)
Morgan Sea (Montreal)
Raphelle Frigon (Montreal)
Lily Butter (Sybil Lamb) (Toronto)
CPI (Ottawa)
Madeline Hoyle (Chicago)
Morgan M Page (Toronto)
and more!
More details soon!
Buddies is a wheelchair accessible venue. More accessibility information coming soon!
*****
This event is being put on entirely out of my own pocket! We have no funders. So please, please come to this event, and tell all your friends, and support trans women and trans-female-spectrum artists!
Facebook event:http://www.facebook.com/events/422484317790868
(via sistahmamaqueen)
good news for trans women & other trans female spectrum folx and those of us who like to have sex with them:
the once super hard to get ahold of “brazen: trans women safer sex guide” by morgan m page (put out by the 519) is now available for download in pdf form!
this is a super important and awesome resource and i’m not really aware of anything else like it out there—i learned a lot of important (and also sexy) stuff reading it and now you can too!
(via hobbitdragon)
Beautiful, and necessary.
Cis people, and cis women specifically, please stop making the cotton ceiling about YOU.
This ain’t about YOUR panties.
This ain’t about “shaming” you into engaging in a sex act you attent interested in. Or using the language of social justice to coerce someone into intimacy or sex with someone…
I love all of this. Especially this passage right here. I’m not trans, so I can’t speak to what it is to enter into trans activist spaces as a trans sex worker and hear this stuff. But I’ve experienced a very similiar dynamic in many queer activist circles and reproductive justice activist circles. It’s “cool” if I do queer, feminist porn (which, for the record, I have done & like doing — but it’s not the only kind of sex work I’ve done). It’s very much NOT cool if I talk about my other experiences working in the sex industry.
Here are some of the dumbass things you’re probably going to hear regularly when you enter non-sex working trans spaces, especially trans activist spaces (and these activists will, of course, lament the lack of involvement from sex workers in their efforts).
Sex work is perfectly fine as a choice, but we need to talk about how survival sex work and “trafficking” are hurting our community!
What they’re actually saying here is that sex work is fine if you have an MA in Women’s Studies and work in queer feminist porn (which they can happily jerk off to without feeling like bad feminists). These same people usually have only a tenuous grasp on the concept of trafficking, probably don’t have any sex workers in their close circle of friends (unless they have the aforementioned MA in Women’s Studies). They are quick to become angry if you suggest that coercive sex work is actually rare, statistically, or that you chose street sex work because it made sense for your life at the time.
All sex work is survival sex work, in exactly the same way that I could describe all jobs at McDonald’s as survival food service jobs.